Carnegie's Maid ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Carnegie's Maid by Marie Benedict
Circa: 1860s
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Overall Enjoyment 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Did it grab and keep my attention? 🎣🎣🎣🎣🎣
There was one little lull where I though I was going to have to take away a 🎣 but as soon as I thought that, hooked again!
Would I refer it to anyone? Yes, no restrictions
Would I want a sequel? N/A, it was wrapped up in the end.
Would I want to read more from this author? ➕Yes, all.the.things.
Trigger Warnings - No
Spice 🌶 No
Plot twist 🌪 No
Tidbits: I thought I might have to deduct a quarter of star because it's more fiction than history. She has said she researches the history and fills in the dark corners with fiction. After listening to the author's note at the end the fictional part made perfect sense and actually held it's own history. In the about it said "...tells the story of one brilliant woman who may have spurred Andrew Carnegie's transformation from ruthless industrialist into the world's first true philanthropist". In real life there wasn't a maid with Clara's circumstances. There WAS someone who turned him from money hungry steel tycoon to charitable humanitarian, history did not document who it was. Maybe another forbidden love. Marie Benedict said she picked a maid based on her own family history of immigrants coming to America and being service workers so she thought "why not the maid who inspires him?". A lot of the maid's story was based on historical facts of immigrants and what their families back in their homeland were dealing with, just not part of Carnegie's story. So basically two POVs colliding.
As you know I do the audio 🎧and it threw me off in the beginning because the narrator pronounces it Car-NiG-Eee. Most American's pronounce it Car-nuh-gee. Like Carnuhgee Hall. I even asked Mr G who responded with the common American pronunciation but there is also a little video, like man-on-the-street. Andrew Carnegie was from Scotland and the people on the street say the Scottish pronunciation is Car-NiG-EEE. Okey dokey then.
That reminds of the former Felene's Department Store in New York. Pronounced Fee-Lines but some called it Fa-lean-ies. Two-may-toe/Tah-mah-toe.
Not from the book, just from history - Andrew Carnegie became the richest man in the world in his 60's until Rockefeller surpassed him in 1910 when he was 74. He didn't marry until he was in his 50s, 20 years after this story's timeframe. He opened thousands of public libraries and gave away most of his fortune (90%). He died at 83 from pneumonia.


Comments
Post a Comment